How Morgan Clark challenged a £150,000 underinsurance penalty and secured a full £400,000 fire damage settlement for a St Ives homeowner.
Location St Ives
Customer Mr Rew
The Incident
The loss occurred when a mobility scooter, plugged into an external socket at the rear of the property, suffered a catastrophic electrical failure. The policyholders heard popping and banging noises before discovering flames and smoke rapidly spreading up the rear elevation and roof. Despite immediate notification to the fire service, the fire spread swiftly, severely gutting the roof structure and causing extensive fire, smoke, and water damage throughout the converted bungalow. Facing an overwhelming situation and unsure how to navigate a claim of this magnitude, the homeowners appointed Morgan Clark following initial guidance from Morgan Clark’s Loss Advisor, Sunny, to manage the entire process on their behalf.
The Challenge
Shortly after the incident, the insurer’s Loss Adjuster issued a formal notice invoking the Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012 (CIDRA). Insurers claimed the policyholder had “carelessly misrepresented” the risk by declaring the home as a 2-bedroom property instead of a 4- or 5-bedroom property based on historical sales listings. As a result, the insurer applied a 38.52% ‘proportional reduction’ underinsurance penalty, stating they would only pay 61.48% of the claim. On a £400,000 claim, this would have left the policyholders facing an out-of-pocket shortfall of roughly £150,000.
The Approach
Morgan Clark mounted a technical and legal defence to challenge the insurer’s penalty while simultaneously driving reinstatement of the property forward:
- Overturning Misrepresentation Claims: Loss assessors Matt Rawlingson and Daniel Norris analysed the insurer’s online proposal tools and statement of fact. They highlighted that the application questions used present-tense phrasing (“is”) regarding property layout. Because the clients legitimately utilised only two rooms as active bedrooms (using the remaining converted space as home offices and study areas), they had answered fully and accurately.
- Applying Legal Principles (Contra Proferentem): Morgan Clark proved that because the insurer failed to provide a clear definition for “intended bedroom use” within their application portal, the question was inherently ambiguous. Legally, any ambiguity in insurer-drafted documentation must be interpreted in favour of the policyholder.
- Proactive Loss Mitigation: While liability was actively in dispute, Morgan Clark immediately deployed a restoration company to salvage, clean, and store unaffected contents, and appointed Surveyors to complete structural engineering inspections and draft reinstatement specifications.
The Results
Confronted with Morgan Clark’s technical arguments and evidence, the insurer’s underwriters conceded that their questioning was open to interpretation and formally withdrew the penalty. Insurers agreed to pay 100% of the £400,000 claim in full.
With full indemnity secured, Morgan Clark successfully advanced full reinstatement plans, covering:
- Complete redesign and reconstruction of the entire roof.
- Complete teardown and rebuild of the upper converted space (including three rooms, a bathroom, hallways, and storage).
- Replacement of the high-spec kitchen and main bathroom.
- Full electrical rewiring, plumbing replacement, and plaster removal throughout the property.