Back to Case Studies

Flood damage to a family home: Securing the maximum settlement and restoring peace of mind following insurer delays

Location Derbyshire 

Customer Trudie Kinirons

“Contacting Morgan Clark was the best decision we made… They literally held us up through what was the worst time in our lives.” 

On 20 October 2023, Trudie Kinirons’ family home was devastated by severe flood damage. Displaced from their property and facing a complex recovery, the family hit immediate roadblocks when dealing directly with their insurance company. 

Over the first six weeks, the insurer appointed three separate Loss Adjusters, forcing Trudie to repeatedly explain her situation and justify her claim. Feeling as though she was “banging her head against a wall” without knowing what she was entitled to, Trudie appointed Morgan Clark to take over the claim and advocate on her behalf. 

The claim 

Morgan Clark Loss Advisor Sunny Singh visited Trudie at her home just days before Christmas to evaluate the damage, offer valuable advice and assign Loss Assessor, Pino Musso, to lead the case. 

The overall claim was valued at more than £300,000, covering the buildings, contents, alternative accommodation and other associated costs. The building repairs alone were valued at £177,000 plus VAT, highlighting the significant scale of the restoration. 

With seven family members displaced, Trudie had to book a four-bedroom holiday let to ensure the family could celebrate Christmas together. Although the insurer initially resisted funding this, Pino successfully challenged their stance, recovering the accommodation expenses in full early in the claim. Additionally, because the family later had to stay in their own holiday rental property during the restoration, Pino negotiated further compensation from the insurer to cover their lost rental income. 

The claim continued for almost 28 months, from the original incident in October 2023 until the insurer issued the final payment in February 2026. Throughout this prolonged and complex negotiation, the insurer repeatedly attempted to minimise liability. Pino maintained persistent pressure on the insurance company while seamlessly coordinating with the Chartered Surveyors and Building Contractors to manage the restoration. 

The results 

Morgan Clark’s persistent advocacy ensured that Trudie received full compensation for expenses she had initially assumed were unclaimable, while Pino continued to challenge the insurer throughout the lengthy claims process. 

The family home was restored to a very high standard, giving Trudie and her family the opportunity to finally move forwards. 

Reflecting on the experience, Trudie said: “Pino fought them with professional determination, resulting in a beautiful full restoration of our home.” She added that without Morgan Clark’s support, “it doesn’t bear thinking about… I don’t know where we’d be now.” 

More Case Studies

Flood Claims

From Flooded & Frustrated to Fully Restored: Securing a Better O...

"When we now consider all that has occurred in the past 18 months, I can say with absolute certainty that the best decision we made was to contact Morgan Clark.” The Background & Initial Assessment When severe flooding struck James and Georgie ..."

Harrogate

Flood Claims

Water Ingress from external drains in Harrogate property: reinstateme...

"Following several issues with external drains, including one that was blocked and one that had collapsed, Mr Burn’s basement suffered an ingress of water, which caused damage to the kitchen, utility and living area. After an initial discussion with th..."

Cockermouth

Flood Claims

Flood insurance claim in 2009 and again in 2015

"The village of Cockermouth hit the national headlines in 2009 when the river Derwent burst its banks after heavy rainfall. Mrs B, whose 17th century cottage backs on to the river, suffered devastating flooding: the water rose to over five feet and she l..."

Carlisle

Flood Claims

Using Morgan Clark a second time for flood insurance claim

"When the river Eden flooded in Carlisle in 2005, water poured through David Allen’s substantial five-bedroomed semi-detached home. There was extensive damage throughout the downstairs which was likely to result in an insurance claim of around £100,00..."

Lancashire

Business Interruption

Flooded bed centre in Lancashire: overturning insurer’s refusal...

"After torrential rain in December 2015, the river Irwell in Rossendale, Lancashire, burst its banks and caused widespread flooding. One of the buildings badly affected was Lamberts Mill, which housed a bed centre on the ground floor. The water rose to t..."

Cumbria

Business Interruption

Flooded bakery in Kendal: £100,000 insurance claim for machinery, st...

"Ginger Bakers is a very successful specialist cake producer based in Kendal, Cumbria, supplying commercial outlets across the country. When Storm Desmond wreaked havoc across the north of England in December 2015, the bakery’s leased premises were hit..."