Annexe fire – £85,000 buildings and contents claim

Location Nottinghamshire

Customer Mr Dyer

Mr Dyer had an unoccupied annexe in the garden of his house in Nottinghamshire. Mrs Dyer stored some of her clothes there and to protect them they regularly used a de-humidifier for short periods. One afternoon, 10 minutes after they had turned it on, they saw smoke pouring from the annexe.

The fire brigade arrived within 20 minutes but the interior of the building was gutted and all contents lost.

The claim 

Mr Dyer had insured the annexe and its contents separately from the main house. He contacted his insurer but was told he was under-insured and would be lucky to receive anything. When the insurer’s loss adjuster arrived, he implied that they had set fire to the annexe themselves.

Mr Dyer realised the claim was going to be a very difficult. After speaking in length to a representative of Morgan Clark, he engaged them to take over control of the claim.

The insurer then carried out a detailed forensic examination of the building and eventually accepted that the de-humidifier had caused the fire. There then followed difficult negotiations over the re-instatement works. Mr Dyer felt the insurer’s nominated contractor did not have the necessary expertise: “They were painters and decorators and weren’t appropriate for dealing with a burnt-out property”.

Mr Dyer decided he would rather use his own local building contractor and oversee the work himself. He therefore wanted a cash settlement, but there was a risk that this would not be sufficient.

There was also a dispute over contents cover. Mrs Dyer’s clothes in the annexe had cost far more than the £5000 policy limit. Morgan Clark therefore invoked the main house’s cover for temporary removal of contents.

The results

After protracted negotiations, the insurer agreed to the following:

  • A cash settlement of just under £60,000 for the buildings claim, much higher than Mr Dyer had expected and sufficient to cover the cost of using his own contractor to carry out the re-instatement.
  • A settlement of £13,000 for contents, which comprised the full £5000 for the annexe contents cover plus £8000 for temporary removal of contents from the main house.

According to Mr Dyer, “Morgan Clark negotiated a far better settlement than I expected and more than earned their fee. They achieved this because they have expertise and experience in dealing with insurers.

“In particular, they put several choices to me on how to proceed, and their care and attention meant everything eventually went well. At the beginning I wondered if I would get anything out of the insurer and in the end I received what I believed I was due.”

More Case Studies

Cambridge

Fire damage in thatched cottage

"Mr and Mrs Hampshire suffered a fire at their thatched cottage, which started in the middle of the night when the family were asleep. The accidental fire was caused by a lighter being ignited, which resulted in blankets and pillows catching fire and ..."

Read more

Cumbria

Flooded bakery in Kendal: £100,000 insurance claim for machinery, st...

"Ginger Bakers is a very successful specialist cake producer based in Kendal, Cumbria, supplying commercial outlets across the country. When Storm Desmond wreaked havoc across the north of England in December 2015, the bakery’s leased premises were ..."

Read more

Cumbria

Flooding at kitchen worktop manufacturer: £1.2 million claim

"Stoneworld is a very successful manufacturer of quartz and granite kitchen worktops, importing expensive materials from across the world and using sophisticated precision cutting machinery. Based in Kendal, Cumbria, it distributes its high-end produc..."

Read more

Carlisle

Using Morgan Clark a second time for flood insurance claim

"When the river Eden flooded in Carlisle in 2005, water poured through David Allen’s substantial five-bedroomed semi-detached home. There was extensive damage throughout the downstairs which was likely to result in an insurance claim of around £100..."

Read more

Doncaster

Flooding – £630,000 business interruption claim

"In 2007, the town of Doncaster was hit by two floods in very quick succession. A large trading estate was very badly affected, including a successful steel processing and stockholding company. Three of its industrial units on the estate were contamin..."

Read more

South Wales

Residential college fire – £1.5m buildings and contents claim

"When an electrical fault caused a major fire at the UWC Atlantic College in South Wales, one of the school’s boarding houses was almost completely destroyed. The College’s immediate priority was to re-house the 52 students who lived there, so it ..."

Read more